Ruger 9e vs Smith & Wesson SD9VE

[CraigAPS]

So, I'm looking at getting my first full size 9mm semi-auto. I'm stuck between the 9E and the SD9VE. I need to stick with something fairly inexpensive (read, "I'm broke!" ). Right now, I can get both for right around $300 online (plus shipping, FFL fees, etc.). I am aware that the 9E only comes with one mag (another $20-$50), but I really like the slide-mounted safety. However, I've heard a lot of good things about the SD9VE, as well. I just wanted to hear some feedback from people who have shot/owned one or the other or both. Good, bad, indifferent. Thanks so much!

 

[DanVoils]

I've had both and kept the 9E and sold the VE. I liked the trigger a lot better on the 9E and it seemed to have a better feel. Both counts made it more accurate for me.

 

[throttletony]

The guy shootong next to me at thr range the other day had both out and said that the 9E seemed picky with ammo. He had tried multiple brands of ammo and he said more than half gave him problems .
I think that sounds like a mag or ejector issue, but he was certain it was the ammo.
Look on other forums also.

The s&w is basic, but it works reliably for my friends who shoot them

 

[pudly]

The guy shootong next to me at thr range the other day had both out and said that the 9E seemed picky with ammo. He had tried multiple brands of ammo and he said more than half gave him problems .
I think that sounds like a mag or ejector issue, but he was certain it was the ammo.
Look on other forums also.

The s&w is basic, but it works reliably for my friends who shoot them

I'd tend to agree that it was likely an issue with his specific setup. The Ruger SR series are not known for being ammo-picky.