ruger lcr or s&w bodyguard 38

[deeno3432]

Im going to buy one of these 2 and Id like input from owners of these 2 revolvers. Id like to know which is better in terms of reliability and durability. Has yours broke or had issues with certain rounds,etc. I know the S&W jframe (442,642,637,etc) are the most popular but I like these two so stick with those please. This gun will be a BUG and main carry at work so I want make the best choice. Thanks

 

[MCgrease08]

I have owned both of these revolvers. Both were very reliable and I never had issues with function or parts. I started with the Bodyguard and liked it OK. I never shot it very accurately and ended up trading it off for a Glock 42 which I came to really dislike, but that's a whole other story.

I traded the Glock 42 for a Ruger LCR which I liked better than the Bodyguard, but I hated the trigger and that Ruger reset. I eventually traded it for a case of ammo. I now use a Ruger LCP as my BUG, but it has that terrible Ruger trigger too.

If my only two options were a Bodyguard or LCR, I would pick the Ruger. If I had the choice to pick something else in a j-frame I would look at a Smith 442, which is what you don't want to hear.

 

[Sullivan_pbr]

I would highly recommend the lcr. I’ve had several and have been very pleased with them. My preference is the lcrx with the ability to fire single action if needed.

 

[mcapo]

If my only two options were a Bodyguard or LCR, I would pick the Ruger. If I had the choice to pick something else in a j-frame I would look at a Smith 442, which is what you don't want to hear.

 

[sliptap]

The LCR is lighter, has much better grip, and a much better trigger. If you haven't already, try both triggers out in person. I think you'll agree the Ruger is smoother. I assume the prices and size are similar. The Smith Bodyguard also has a non-traditional cylinder release, which threw me off.

Between only those two choices, I'd go for an LCR hands down.

As someone who owns both an LCR and 360J (basically a 437), the smaller size of the 360J/437 makes a big difference for me while pocket carrying. My Smith isn't as easy to shoot, but it's what travels with me most. I know you don't want to hear it, but the smaller size 442/642/637 etc. is more convenient for carry...which means I actually take it with me.

I am happy to answer questions on/offline, take comparison pics, etc. if that helps your decision. Let me know!


EDIT: you asked about durability. You shouldn't have problems from either. If you do, then both companies have great warranties and reputations. I wouldn't stress as much about durability.

 

[Tyler-The-Piker]

I've had experience with both of these and I'd vote LCR but in .357