1911: Kimber? Springfield? or ?

[cedarhillfarms11]

I'm a colt guy but also hold kimbers and springfields in high regard. Rock Islands and such are great guns, but I personally would gather up the other $150-$200 that it would take to pick up a lightly used, higher valued piece. Be patient and buy used and you won't get hurt on a resale. If you are determined to buy new then Rock Island would be my choice.

 

[Harleyrider_50]

I want to purchase my first 1911. On a limited budget, but don't wanna go super cheap. It will be for my CC/OC for when I'm not at work. Not too into decorative grips and such. Plain all black will do just nicely. Need some advice. (purchase is more future, say six months at min. I just want to do my homework)

Haha......If yer on a limit'd budget dude, ya wanna stay away from those 2, haha!.....They are fine weapons,not for the faint of wallet....just say'n.....

 

[Lock n Load]

Since this will be a future purchase check out the different makes and models at the shops and see what you really need/ want in a 1911. This will help decide how much $$ you need/ want to spend.

Can you buy a stripped down bare bones 1911 or since its a CCW pistol at least have NS, extended slide release etc... (examples only)

Ive had great luck with my Kimbers, and they come with some of the extras that alot of folks end up adding to the base pistols later anyhow.... thus increasing the price.

Shop around, see what your likes and dislikes are and look for a good used 1911.

Good luck and keep us posted,

 

[blue edge]

My Vote 9MM or 45


http://shootersconnectionstore.com/STI-Spartan-45-Stocked-Item-P967.aspx


Also the guys at Shooters Connection are easy to get along with. Just tell them I sent you and you will get an extra discount.

HA!HAH!AH!A!HA!

 

[dondavis3]

I love my Kimber

It's a great gun

But they are expensive.

 

[KAS]

I just went through this same dilemma over which 1911. I wanted something with some historical integrity, as the 1911 is a historical gun. However, I also wanted some of the more modern features that technology provides. I looked at and shot Kimbers, Colts, Wilson Combats, etc. All very nice guns but i wanted to be under $1,000. So, I looked at less expensive options: Rock Island, GI models & Range Officer. In the end, I bought a Springfield Armory Loaded: historical significance, glued metal and walnut grips to remain semi-true to the original and modern features of skeletonized trigger, trijicon night sights and modern, looped hammer. All for just over $800!

 

[Rob377]

If it were me, I'd opt for the Kimber. I have this OCD thing about buying the quintessential American handgun, the 1911, with a Brazilian made frame. Springfield 1911 frames are made by Imbel. It's like buying a American Flag made in China. It's just wrong.

 

[LLDJR]

I want to purchase my first 1911. On a limited budget, but don't wanna go super cheap. It will be for my CC/OC for when I'm not at work. Not too into decorative grips and such. Plain all black will do just nicely. Need some advice. (purchase is more future, say six months at min. I just want to do my homework)

What is your budget, IMO, for $700 you can not beat a Kimber Custom II*** for less, you would have to "hope" to find a good used 1911


For the "lowest cost" the Rock Island Armory seems to be a popular low cost 1911 at @ $400


Rock Island Armory - 1911-A1 Parkerized, .45 ACP

 

[mikeplan14]

Kimbers have excellent fit and finish, and shoot dead nuts! I kick myself every day for selling my SIS Custom...

 

[Regionnus Rattis]

If you can find a way to get it, here is a "limited budget" 1911.

I know I'd go out and buy one

Marstar Canada: Norinco M-1911A1 'Sport Model' (Two-Tone) .45 ACP Handgun

 

[Sticky]

I like the Springfield Mil-spec with a flat mainspring housing. It's a good shooter with decent sights. I have one of their Loaded models too, and it shoots good. I use the Mil-spec much more often. Not sure why.

 

[gunman41mag]

I would save my money & buy a real nice 1911. I like my DETONICS SCOREMASTER & COLT GOLD CUP NATIONAL MATCH

 

[elpenguin0717]

haha im in the same dilemma but i think im just gonna suck it up make some sacrifices and shell out the extra bucks for a colt lol

 

[gunman41mag]

haha im in the same dilemma but i think im just gonna suck it up make some sacrifices and shell out the extra bucks for a colt lol

I learned a while back, to buy guns that make my H A P P Y Even if I have to spend some $$$

 

[elpenguin0717]

hahaha ya thats what i was realizing.....do it right the first time lol

 

[dondavis3]

+1 elpenguin0717

I'd rather buy a high quality "used" gun than a "new" poor quality gun any time.

 

[Wild Deuce]

I had an issue with Kimber that I didn't have with Springfield Armory ... it's here.

Summary:

Kimber Custom Shop builds me a gun. Plunger tube comes loose after less than 5k rounds (remember this is a $1900+ Custom Shop gun). Kimber wants to charge me for overnight shipping (both ways) to have it repaired since it is past the warranty period.

Springfield Armory, on the other hand, has handled every issue on their dime. I'm not just talking about defects or repairs. This has included adjustments or tweaks.
​

This could be why I own one Kimber and four Springfields.

Remember, you're not just buying a gun. You are also buying a relationship with a manufacuturer. Hopefully, you will not need to develop that relationship but it's nice to know that they will stand by their product all the way.

 

[GlockRyan]

Kimber makes pretty nice guns.

 

[Cherryspringer]

How come you aren't considering colt? Are they not worthy by today's standards or what? I'm just asking.

 

[unforgiven1203]

I'd go kimber, american made and theres nothing better in the price range.