You just havent found the right one yet. There are all sorts of barrel, grip, and frame combinations and modifications. The 1911 is like the old GI joe doll for grown up men. If the 45 ACP is a turn off, you can always look for the neutered version in 9mm, or step it up and go for a 45 super or 460 rowland.
-
Be sure to read this post! Beware of scammers. https://www.indianagunowners.com/threads/classifieds-new-online-payment-guidelines-rules-paypal-venmo-zelle-etc.511734/
1911 please don't flame me
- Thread starter jkfletcher
- Start date
The #1 community for Gun Owners in Indiana
Member Benefits:
Fewer Ads! Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership Discuss anti-gun legislation Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses Discover free outdoor shooting areas View up to date on firearm-related events Share photos & video with other members ...and so much more!
Member Benefits:
You just havent found the right one yet. There are all sorts of barrel, grip, and frame combinations and modifications. The 1911 is like the old GI joe doll for grown up men. If the 45 ACP is a turn off, you can always look for the neutered version in 9mm, or step it up and go for a 45 super or 460 rowland.
I love 'em, always have. I like my Glock and others but my 1911's feel like an extension of my hand. And .45 isn't that much more than .40, shoot one and you will be hooked I am afraid.
Probably the best description: it's love. No more, no less, than love. Out of all the manufacturers, most have put out their own take on the 1911. Out of all the makes, models, action and calibers that get the job done, the 1911 STILL holds its place.
A properly built 1911 is like marrying the General Lee's power to a Lexus ride: damn close to ecstacy.
Welcome to the pistol Holy Wars my friend.
1911's will lead you to "the custom path", which will put a BIG dent in your wallet.
I love the triggers on my 1911s. I like the thumb safety and grip safety features (although these features can be found on the other pistol architectures).
There's a 100+ years of experience, design improvements, and modern manufacturing techniques behind the 1911 and I'd love to hear a master gunsmith's answer to your question.
As mentioned in one of the posts, find someone that will let you run a few practice strings with their custom 1911 and enjoy the trigger.
Back to the religious reference ... I've owned grocks, etc. for 2+ decades and was introduced to the 1911 about 2 years ago. I submit for your consideration that personal preferences are heavily influenced by the person or persons that invest time and effort to show you how to run a pistol. I was/am very fortunate to have a few very experienced individuals take me under their wing and they run with the 1911. I've grown quite fond of my 1911's as the muscle memory has developed nicely over this time period. The basics, presentation, proper grip, trigger manipulation, various reload techniques, clearing malfunctions, flashlight techniques, and back to the holster.
On occasion, I think about pulling the G17 out of the safe and see if I can make it run as efficiently as the CQB. But it doesn't last long as I have much work left to do with the 1911.
Bottomline, at least where I'm at in this journey:
#1 - shoot and carry equipment that you have validated and know will run on demand,
#2 - shoot and carry equipment that you can control and get the hits.
There's many experts out there that have shown the job can get done with either pistol architecture.
Good luck!
1911's will lead you to "the custom path", which will put a BIG dent in your wallet.
I love the triggers on my 1911s. I like the thumb safety and grip safety features (although these features can be found on the other pistol architectures).
There's a 100+ years of experience, design improvements, and modern manufacturing techniques behind the 1911 and I'd love to hear a master gunsmith's answer to your question.
As mentioned in one of the posts, find someone that will let you run a few practice strings with their custom 1911 and enjoy the trigger.
Back to the religious reference ... I've owned grocks, etc. for 2+ decades and was introduced to the 1911 about 2 years ago. I submit for your consideration that personal preferences are heavily influenced by the person or persons that invest time and effort to show you how to run a pistol. I was/am very fortunate to have a few very experienced individuals take me under their wing and they run with the 1911. I've grown quite fond of my 1911's as the muscle memory has developed nicely over this time period. The basics, presentation, proper grip, trigger manipulation, various reload techniques, clearing malfunctions, flashlight techniques, and back to the holster.
On occasion, I think about pulling the G17 out of the safe and see if I can make it run as efficiently as the CQB. But it doesn't last long as I have much work left to do with the 1911.
Bottomline, at least where I'm at in this journey:
#1 - shoot and carry equipment that you have validated and know will run on demand,
#2 - shoot and carry equipment that you can control and get the hits.
There's many experts out there that have shown the job can get done with either pistol architecture.
Good luck!
Yes you can.
You can, and it shows up in his box when he goes to User CP. He, like me, just has it blocked to public view. But just in case, I got him for you!
This is a surprisingly good answer, and I hadn't considered it that way.
Too bad I can't rep you
You can, and it shows up in his box when he goes to User CP. He, like me, just has it blocked to public view. But just in case, I got him for you!
jakemartens
Master
I don't know what it is about the 1911 but I have about 50 of them (lost count, could be more) of them in my safes, house, cars, belt holsters . . .
Or at least I did up until that tragic boating accident shortly after Obama got elected and all my guns ended up on the bottom of Lake Michigan.
Or at least I did up until that tragic boating accident shortly after Obama got elected and all my guns ended up on the bottom of Lake Michigan.
You too huh? shot my dad's 6" S&W .357 then my Uncle's Colt 1911 and except for size of the holes, almost identical groups.
After I get my AR15 then its on to saving my pennies, nickles, and dimes for a 1911!!!!
halfmileharry
Grandmaster
A 1911 is kinda like your favorite jeans or boots. They fit and they're comfortable.
You can bet your life on 'em.
I've been carrying one for over 40 years and it's one of those special guns I can grab in a dead sleep and it's just a familiar part of me.
From the first time I held a 1911 nothing else has fit like it.
I prefer it in .45acp. I don't have to worry about a lot of ammo choices as I'm comfortable in knowing it'll do the job the first time.
There's other guns I like. The Sig and HK are good shooters but the old reliable 1911 single action is for me.
You can bet your life on 'em.
I've been carrying one for over 40 years and it's one of those special guns I can grab in a dead sleep and it's just a familiar part of me.
From the first time I held a 1911 nothing else has fit like it.
I prefer it in .45acp. I don't have to worry about a lot of ammo choices as I'm comfortable in knowing it'll do the job the first time.
There's other guns I like. The Sig and HK are good shooters but the old reliable 1911 single action is for me.
1911's are just cool. 
Pretty IMHO
Accurate as hell.
SAO (which has now changed - you can get a few DA/SA 1911)
Everyone needs to own one at least.
As said above .. go spend some time shooting a 1911.
Then you'll understand
Pretty IMHO
Accurate as hell.
SAO (which has now changed - you can get a few DA/SA 1911)
Everyone needs to own one at least.
As said above .. go spend some time shooting a 1911.
Then you'll understand
Last edited:
The weight and steel construction of a 1911 frame pistol are what I consider worthy to be called a weapon. I have shot single action 1911s since I was a boy with my grandfather and his govt issue Colt. I remember 15 years ago when my cousin brought his new Glock to my house to shoot and show. I remember how when I held it I was thinking " WOW, WHAT A CHINCY P.O S.", I understand now that Glocks are good guns, but that doesnt take away that to me they feel like toys instead of weapons. I prefer 1911s because they feel sturdy, strong, and if all else fails you can club the hell out of someone with it. If I clubbed you with a Glock it would merely **** you off! Lol
gunman41mag
Shooter
I just live without a 1911
1911s are great guns. Once firing one, most people will like them. I did. And I love my Glocks.
With all that said, I still don't want to be clubbed in the head with a polymer pistol. The slide is still metal and the plastic is strong. Yeah, it's gonna hurt. I'd be more worried about it breaking and gouging me like a dull knife. My assessment..I'll keep both.
With all that said, I still don't want to be clubbed in the head with a polymer pistol. The slide is still metal and the plastic is strong. Yeah, it's gonna hurt. I'd be more worried about it breaking and gouging me like a dull knife. My assessment..I'll keep both.
Drunken Yak inc
Plinker
You are absolutely correct! I named my Ultra Raptor II Camilla, never bothered to formally name any of my other guns... The non-1911 guns just give off a more utilitarian vibe...
