If you will be traveling in rural southern Indiana, Verizon has better coverage just about everywhere. I have AT&T and they suck - other people talking on the phone when I have no service and I ask them who they have and they always say Verizon. I'm on a grandfathered family plan with AT&T that makes it too cheap to switch to Verizon. No way would I go AT&T today if I was starting fresh.