Best AR15 bolt carrier group?

[AngryRooster]

I've put this up a couple of times when it seems relevant. I'm usually reluctant to do so since it sometimes causes butthurt. Yep, I know ARFCOM isn't the greatest source of knowledge, but it has merit in this case. It's an older thread from a few years ago when BCGs were next to impossible to get and were going for a premium regardless of brand. Some of the pictures are now gone, but most are still there. Read the ENTIRE thread, don't just stop on page 1 or 2. It will illustrate why I no longer shop at PSA as well as why I no longer participate in any section on ARFCOM outside of the HAM radio section. A bit off topic, be happy our mods are not like the one in that discussion. Won't take much to figure out which post is mine. Guy is a complete
View attachment 50936



https://www.ar15.com/forums/t_3_118/610107_Received_the_PSA_BCG_Pictures_included.html&page=1

 

[zx854613]

You should try different bands. different people have different feedback.

 

[cobber]

I've put this up a couple of times when it seems relevant. I'm usually reluctant to do so since it sometimes causes butthurt. Yep, I know ARFCOM isn't the greatest source of knowledge, but it has merit in this case. It's an older thread from a few years ago when BCGs were next to impossible to get and were going for a premium regardless of brand. Some of the pictures are now gone, but most are still there. Read the ENTIRE thread, don't just stop on page 1 or 2. It will illustrate why I no longer shop at PSA as well as why I no longer participate in any section on ARFCOM outside of the HAM radio section. A bit off topic, be happy our mods are not like the one in that discussion. Won't take much to figure out which post is mine. Guy is a complete
View attachment 50936



https://www.ar15.com/forums/t_3_118/610107_Received_the_PSA_BCG_Pictures_included.html&page=1

Nice link, thanks!

 

[cobber]

And do bolts get 'worn in' to the lugs/chamber over time, or can you simply switch BCGs among different rifles?

I have a WMD BCG in my frankengun that I would like to move to my new PSA build, and then get a new BCG for frank.

Any problem with that?

 

[Fizzerpilot]

I use ones with a lifetime warranty

 

[AngryRooster]

I prefer to use ones that are built properly, out of the proper materials, so I don't have to use the warranty.

 

[warthog]

I prefer to use ones that are built properly, out of the proper materials, so I don't have to use the warranty.

yes and so far I haven't had a lick of trouble in five rifles with Brownell's brand phosphate milspec bolts and carriers. I tried a chromed one, it does clean a lot easier but wasn't worth the extra money. Brownell's also guarantees their stuff in case something happens though I have yet to need that guarantee.

 

[AngryRooster]

yes and so far I haven't had a lick of trouble in five rifles with Brownell's brad phosphate milspec bolts and carriers. I tried a chromed one, it does clean a lot easier but wasn't worth the extra money. Brownell's also guarantees their stuff in case something happens though I have yet to need that guarantee.

Brownells usually has pretty good quality stuff when it comes to something their name is on. It looks like that BCG is good to go. Each one HP/MPI and everything else looks to spec as well. I usually run BCM's when I get a separate BCG but would not feel bad about one of the Brownells at all.

 

[24Carat]

I've had a burning desire to put a Sharps Rifle Company BCG through its paces.

 

[HnK]

And do bolts get 'worn in' to the lugs/chamber over time, or can you simply switch BCGs among different rifles?

I have a WMD BCG in my frankengun that I would like to move to my new PSA build, and then get a new BCG for frank.

Any problem with that?

Only way to know for sure is with a go/no go gauge. Some can some can't.

 

[hANNAbONE]

BCM...

 

[Thegeek]

Buy a used Smith and Wesson from someone who thought they needed a high end one.

 

[Maximinus Thrax]

I've been pondering this myself lately. My first AR build is running a PSA "premium" BCG that I got last year after Thanksgiving. The carrier itself is okay. I wish it were a little easier to clean the inside but all in all, it's been good to me. I did have a failure of one of my gas rings last month. I've yet to run 1k rounds through it so I was surprised to have to replace one this soon but now I have a dozen spares, I'm good to go in that department.

I'm thinking I may pony up to a different BCG, I just haven't decided which one yet.

 

[Springer]

BCM, DD, Colt, LMT. A few smaller companies putting out quality parts are Sionics and Sons of Liberty Gun Works.

 

[Hohn]

I've had a burning desire to put a Sharps Rifle Company BCG through its paces.

I saw vids of Relia-bolt breakage on the lugs. Bad heat treat batch?

 

[jgressley2003]

I'm glad this thread came up since I'm in the process of building my first AR. I was just going to find the cheapest option, but now I've narrowed my option down to Spikes and Fail Zero with the nickel coating.

 

[seedubs1]

Almost forgot about Sionics. Their bolts are apparently the bees knees. I wouldn't hesitate to run one of theirs. And their NP3 coating is apparently excellent as well. I wouldn't run NiB or nitrided BCG's due to issues with those coatings/processes, but that's just me.

BCM, DD, Colt, LMT. A few smaller companies putting out quality parts are Sionics and Sons of Liberty Gun Works.

 

[bmbutch]

I have BCM, ZIESS, Spikes, & AIM Surplus. ZIESS had a dimensional issue, but they took care of it via replacement. Getting ready to order a couple (likely Spikes or BCM) before election, 1-for 11.5" SBR (sent in eform in June) & 1 for a spare.

 

[Bfish]

I think there are tons of great options mentioned here... I've got a fail zero I picked up on black Friday I think last year maybe the year before way less than I see them gookg for now. I would say the FZ is my favorite and I'll buy more if I see them for the right price here soon.

 

[cobber]

I'm also a bit perplexed on finishes. I have two phosphate BCGs that seem almost gritty when charging but seem to run fine on the range, and one NIB BCG (WMD) that runs very smoothly at least when charging. Thinking I'll get some sort of 'slick' finish in a new BCG.

Is this my imagination?