I should’ve better qualified who can see it, and who just sees “it” with wistful aspirations.Have you forgotten all the pressure put on Poulian over Manning vs Leaf? To me, and apparently you, it was a no brainer but there was much discussion. Then there was the Luck vs RGIII questions. So not everyone “knew”.
Yeah. A lot of folks thought Leaf had “it”. Character is a big part of having “it”. Leaf blew off the pre-draft meeting with the colts. Manning didn’t. I’ve heard people speculate that’s why Manning got picked over Leaf by the colts.
I think there’s a lot more evidence on Manning’s side. Leaf really had just one great year of his three in college. That was his Heisman year. Manning had a qb rating of mid to upper 140’s each of his *4* years.
It was controversial, and really easy in hindsight for us to pick which of them had “it”. But just because it was controversial then does not mean the controversy was earned. I think it was a no-brainer.