Going from a Barska to a Vortex is more than just an upgrade; it's more like a quantum leap forward.
That's a fact. I put a Barska on my 45-70, 5 rounds later the scope was toast. I put a Bushnell Banner on it and so far its holding up.
Going from a Barska to a Vortex is more than just an upgrade; it's more like a quantum leap forward.
No, not sacrilege; it's practical.
Lots of folks don't have nearly the visual acuity that they had when they were younger.
Also, there have been some significant technological advances with .30-30 ammo, especially Hornady's LeveRevolution ammo and FTX component bullets, that greatly extend the effective range of the .30-30 such that a moderate bit of magnification helps at the roughly 200-250 yards now practical with the new ammo, and having the target and the aiming point more or less in focus -- impossible to accomplish with iron sights, mind you -- helps aiming precision to ensure a humane shot.
We don't call it silly or sacrilege for those who prudently wear hearing protection, so why do we scoff at people who choose to acknowledge reality with the limitations of their eyesight who respond by improving their odds of getting a precision shot to ethically bring down their game?
A 30-30 is basically a good 150 yard shell, if your hunting in the brush or woods less than that. For Dear or even preditors I'd suggest you leave the scope off. You can aquire your prey quicker with open sights and any decent shot doesn't need a scope for a 100 yard shot, unless of course you are as old as I am then you need the scope just to see your target.
Second suggestion, Skinner or Williams peep sights. Much better than Semi Buckhorn and fully windage and elevation adjustable.
I appreciate everyone's input. Doesn't seem to be to many strong opinions about the initial question, more important - additional magnification vs illuminated reticle, but the comments have been helpful. I need a short LOP to make a rifle fit right and always struggle to get a good eye relief with most scoped. I have a fixed 2.75 scout on a .357 lever and do like that setup. I am leaning towards the 2-7x32mm scout scope for the greater eye relief and likely faster acquisition.