Really depends on what you want it for. If you just want another full size gun for your collection, take your pick. Any of them should serve you well. I've owned all three:
...
If you want something to match your full size M&P, you might try the new M&P 2.0 Compact. It will take your full size mags, and they are getting really good reviews. (I haven't shot one yet). Or if you want something smaller for concealed carry, an M&P 9c (the old model) is a good choice.
This. We really need to know a bit more about purpose of the new firearm. I'm generally in favor of staying with a platform, unless there is some specific reason not too. The M&P compact 2.0 would be a nice addition since you already have an M&P (share mags, holsters, etc). I don't own any of the others mentioned that you were interested in to make an informed recommendation.