Mandrel Sizing / Neck Tension

The #1 community for Gun Owners in Indiana

Member Benefits:

  • Fewer Ads!
  • Discuss all aspects of firearm ownership
  • Discuss anti-gun legislation
  • Buy, sell, and trade in the classified section
  • Chat with Local gun shops, ranges, trainers & other businesses
  • Discover free outdoor shooting areas
  • View up to date on firearm-related events
  • Share photos & video with other members
  • ...and so much more!
  • Rating - 100%
    44   0   0
    Nov 23, 2008
    2,742
    12
    Mishawaka
    I've been chasing a load for my 6.5 Creedmoor and shooting a Savage 110 Precision mounted in a MDT chassis. For a lot of years I've been just using the standard full length seating die (non bushing). I've experimented both ways of just full length resizing and collet neck sizing. Side note: I also anneal. While i've been getting descent numbers past my Labradar, i've just never got that fuzzy feeling of "That's the load!". I would get sub groups of about .8 and sometimes larger but never that consistent sub group bliss.

    Fast forward, I've played with powder charges in .1 increments and found that node. Then play with OAL and BTO and got that tuned but knew it was still missing a final piece of the puzzle. Then i learned about mandrel dies and boy i'm glad I did. I purchased a full length bushing sizing die and removed the expander ball and stem. I size the brass and the bushing sizes the neck just undersize with a .003 smaller bushing. The magic happened when I skipped the collet die and just used the mandrel die to open the neck to the perfect diameter (.002 bullet tension) and rounding the neck at the same time. My neck tension is now perfectly where it should be. Who'da thunk that neck tension was this important? I mean, i always knew it was but didn't realize how good a mandrel die was to getting it and figured the FL die was good enough.

    The chrono numbers drastically reduced and I was so amazed that i almost thought something was wrong with the Labradar.

    10 shot group

    Average
    2748.48
    Highest
    2752.47
    Lowest
    2743.7
    Ext. Spread
    8.77
    Std. Dev
    3.25

    I followed up these numbers with the next 4 groups and the results were also showing up on the target. Thrilled to say the least!

    Theory is from some world class shooters is to remove the expanding ball and stem in a full length seating die because when the expander ball is pulled back out of the neck it can slightly mis-align the neck thus the reason to remove it completely and either use a collet die or a mandrel die. From my trips to the range I've opted now for the mandrel die.


    This may be old hat to some but after reloading for almost 20 years I guess I'm late to the party but glad I've finally got there. Now i need to order a mandrel for my .308 RPR.
     
    Last edited:

    TangoFoxtrot

    Expert
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Jul 22, 2018
    1,352
    83
    United states
    I've been chasing a load for my 6.5 Creedmoor and shooting a Savage 110 Precision mounted in a MDT chassis. For a lot of years I've been just using the standard full length seating die (non bushing). I've experimented both ways of just full length resizing and collet neck sizing. Side note: I also anneal. While i've been getting descent numbers past my Labradar, i've just never got that fuzzy feeling of "That's the load!". I would get sub groups of about .8 and sometimes larger but never that consistent sub group bliss.

    Fast forward, I've played with powder charges in .1 increments and found that node. Then play with OAL and BTO and got that tuned but knew it was still missing a final piece of the puzzle. Then i learned about mandrel dies and boy i'm glad I did. I purchased a full length bushing sizing die and removed the expander ball and stem. I size the brass and the bushing sizes the neck just undersize with a .003 smaller bushing. The magic happened when I skipped the collet die and just used the mandrel die to open the neck to the perfect diameter (.002 bullet tension) and rounding the neck at the same time. My neck tension is now perfectly where it should be. Who'da thunk that neck tension was this important? I mean, i always knew it was but didn't realize how good a mandrel die was to getting it and figured the FL die was good enough.

    The chrono numbers drastically reduced and I was so amazed that i almost thought something was wrong with the Labradar.

    10 shot group

    Average
    2748.48
    Highest
    2752.47
    Lowest
    2743.7
    Ext. Spread
    8.77
    Std. Dev
    3.25

    I followed up these numbers with the next 4 groups and the results were also showing up on the target. Thrilled to say the least!

    Theory is from some world class shooters is to remove the expanding ball and stem in a full length seating die because when the expander ball is pulled back out of the neck it can slightly mis-align the neck thus the reason to remove it completely and either use a collet die or a mandrel die. From my trips to the range I've opted now for the mandrel die.


    This may be old hat to some but after reloading for almost 20 years I guess I'm late to the party with but glad I've finally got there. Now i need to order a mandrel for my .308 RPR.
    I already had seperate bushing neck only dies so I just pit my pin and mandrel in a drill press and used 800 grit to take a touch off at a time, the advantage I found doing that is the occasional bent mouth where I missed the ejection and it hit the concrete , it still fixes that

    Sent from my SM-N975U using Tapatalk
     

    jbrubaker

    Plinker
    Rating - 0%
    0   0   0
    Sep 22, 2010
    50
    6
    Elkhart
    Thanks for sharing that info. I typically either regular full-length resize for a 0.002" shoulder bump or use a Lee Collet Die if I am being lazy and not interested in lubricating anything. I've heard mandrels and bushings are the way to go, but just haven't taken the plunge yet. I'll have to consider the possibilities there again!
     
    Top Bottom