Should doctor be fired from residency for her actions?

[KittySlayer]

She is a neurologist, not a neurosurgeon. Evaluate the nervous system but no scalpels.

So she is a Brain Scientist, not a Brain Surgeon.

 

[jsharmon7]

I don't care that she has a stressful job. I don't care that she was intoxicated and not thinking clearly. I don't care that she's invested a great deal into becoming a doctor. If you make a mistake you live with the consequences. However, no charges were filed and she was not on the clock or acting on behalf of her employer/program in any way. I don't see why her personal life should impact her career unless this is bringing negative attention to her actual employer. If personal decisions start to affect work though, I think it's time to go. That goes for any job though.

 

[Fargo]

.


I'm tired of people playing the class-card in these situations, depending on the level of education, who she knows, where she works, how many letters of support she can gather.

I've only seen one person play the class card in this thread...

For a thread about employment, you seem awfully fixated on arguing for prosecution of people based on their social status.

 

[indiucky]

"So how did a nice, smart girl like you end up in porn?"

"Got drunk and smacked down an UBER driver....Now here...Tie me off right there above the elbow...That's it...Yep...That vein there...The one by the RR tracks..."

 

[IndyDave1776]

First, I am not going to even try to justify this individual's actions, but if we apply the same standard of justice, 95% of our elected officials would either spend the rest of their lives in federal prison or be swinging from one of those five-stranded hemp ropes they insist on prohibiting us from growing, yet the argument there is always that we should make noise, be the squeaky wheel, and beg and grovel for our constitutional rights. Hillary has been caught dead to rights in criminal activity that endangers national security and scarcely generates the response that a young woman having an alcohol-induced stupid attack receives. Why is this?

 

[IndyDave1776]

"So how did a nice, smart girl like you end up in porn?"

"Got drunk and smacked down an UBER driver....Now here...Tie me off right there above the elbow...That's it...Yep...That vein there...The one by the RR tracks..."

 

[BehindBlueI's]

I doubt she would have fought this in court, with that video. A good attorney would have her cop to a pre-trial diversion and hope the publicity faded quickly and in the meantime get her into a program and smooth things out with the hospital.

A trial? That would be a true sign of insanity.

People get arrested, charged and convicted for the same every day. Miami PD elected not to arrest her, but back to my original point, this behavior was in no way a 'mistake'.

You are confusing mistake with accident.

 

[BehindBlueI's]

I'm really surprised by the "Let her keep her job" camp and how well they've rallied the troops. Of course it might have something to do with young, professional, female, great body; it'd be interesting to see if the voting came in identical if the drunk had been an overweight trash truck driver. Of course who couldn't predict the outcome of that poll?

Why are you trying to make it a discrimination issue? Any evidence?

 

[GodFearinGunTotin]

First, I am not going to even try to justify this individual's actions, but if we apply the same standard of justice, 95% of our elected officials would either spend the rest of their lives in federal prison or be swinging from one of those five-stranded hemp ropes they insist on prohibiting us from growing, yet the argument there is always that we should make noise, be the squeaky wheel, and beg and grovel for our constitutional rights. Hillary has been caught dead to rights in criminal activity that endangers national security and scarcely generates the response that a young woman having an alcohol-induced stupid attack receives. Why is this?

Maybe they're waiting for someone to press charges?

Kinda like that doc-wanna-be, people have invested a ton of money in Hillary. We can't allow one lapse in information security judgement to ruin a promising career and the waste of such investments.

 

[Fargo]

Why are you trying to make it a discrimination issue? Any evidence?

For Miami, she isn't even particularly attractive. Police respond to thousands of bar fights daily across all social spectrums, many/most of them don't result in arrests. I am unclear why this one is so special.

 

[PaulF]

For Miami, she isn't even particularly attractive. Police respond to thousands of bar fights daily across all social spectrums, many/most of them don't result in arrests. I am unclear why this one is so special.

For Boone County she in an exotic princess!

 

[dcr465]

Why was this on ch 13 several times yesterday??? HOW IS THIS "NEWS"

 

[IndyDave1776]

Why was this on ch 13 several times yesterday??? HOW IS THIS "NEWS"

 

[hoosierdoc]

For Boone County she in an exotic princess!

"Wow, you're exotic, was your dad in the navy?"

 

[femurphy77]

Why are you trying to make it a discrimination issue? Any evidence?

Purely anecdotal and entirely too lazy to look it up. You know as well as anybody on this forum that wealth and privilege, be it monetary or physical appearance, or fame due to a "leaked" porn video can buy a lot of forgiveness and adoration in this country. An easy example is affluenza boy. Kills how many people drunk driving and gets off essentially scot free because of his and his families wealth and position in life. There's never an outcry from the easily distracted sheep when it's a fat garbage truck driver because there's nothing "ist" about it or anything else to get panties wadded over hence no viral video, no news spots several times a day, no reality show offer, etc. etc. Of course I've become quite cynical over the past several years so maybe it's just me.

 

[Fargo]

Purely anecdotal and entirely too lazy to look it up. You know as well as anybody on this forum that wealth and privilege, be it monetary or physical appearance, or fame due to a "leaked" porn video can buy a lot of forgiveness and adoration in this country. An easy example is affluenza boy. Kills how many people drunk driving and gets off essentially scot free because of his and his families wealth and position in life. There's never an outcry from the SJW's when it's a fat garbage truck driver because there's nothing "ist" about it or anything else to get panties wadded over hence no viral video, no news spots several times a day, no reality show offer, etc. etc. Of course I've become quite cynical over the past several years so maybe it's just me.

I was unaware the SJW's consider attractive doctors an oppressed class. If anything, I thought it was the opposite...

I also was unaware that the ranks of law enforcement and hospital management were now dominated by SJWs?

 

[Kutnupe14]

I don't care that she has a stressful job. I don't care that she was intoxicated and not thinking clearly. I don't care that she's invested a great deal into becoming a doctor. If you make a mistake you live with the consequences. However, no charges were filed and she was not on the clock or acting on behalf of her employer/program in any way. I don't see why her personal life should impact her career unless this is bringing negative attention to her actual employer. If personal decisions start to affect work though, I think it's time to go. That goes for any job though.

It has certainly brought negative attention to her employer, evident by the fact that her employer was notified, and had to make a statement concerning the issue. Many in the public would question how professional, and thus competent, a hospital's overall staff is, if they employ such a person.

 

[Expat]

I was unaware the SJW's consider attractive doctors an oppressed class. If anything, I thought it was the opposite...

I also was unaware that the ranks of law enforcement and hospital management were now dominated by SJWs?

Men of any group will, from time to time, sacrifice their principles at the chance of getting laid.

 

[Fargo]

Men of any group will, from time to time, sacrifice their principles at the chance of getting laid.

Duly noted, but in a town like Miami I doubt it is for her...

 

[Expat]

Duly noted, but in a town like Miami I doubt it is for her...

Noted as well, my judgement could be affected by the sturdy Mennonite and Amish women I am used to seeing.