For temp usages I prefer Yak-Traks...
Did you check the price, or go off of the tag? The Menards in Avon had them all tagged at $2, but when I went to the one in Westfield for a generator they were all tagged at the normal $9.99, but the $2 price was still good when scanned.Must have been a special, today at my local Menards they were $9.99 so I passed.
I generally use Yak-Traks. I have all three versions.