I got M1 Garand project

[Orlando8]

uncut op rods are not dangerous to fire. Yes it is " possible" they could crack at theright angle but there has never been a incident recorded of a injury from one cracking

 

[Winamac]

uncut op rods are not dangerous to fire. Yes it is " possible" they could crack at theright angle but there has never been a incident recorded of a injury from one cracking

I never indicated that an injury had occurred? However knowing that they CAN crack and have a fully documented history of doing so. Why would one want to take the chance of possible damage to the rifle as well as ruin a collectible op-rod? I simply suggested that it is not recommended to shoot them. It is up to the individual. I personally would not.

 

[Orlando8]

You said it was dangerous so that would lead one to believe it has caused injury
Not trying to argue just making statement
There is alot of incorrect info being repeated on the internet, such as the reason op rods cracked is becuase of firing grenades. This is also a internet myth
I have all correct SA 1941, SA 1943, SA 1944 and SA 1945 Garands all with uncut op rods and I do shoot them all. Am I taking a chance on them breaking? Maybe but the chance is very small. If it does crack I will simply buy another, they are not hard to find or that much premium over a standard op rod.
Just my opinion

 

[Winamac]

You said it was dangerous so that would lead one to believe it has caused injury
Not trying to argue just making statement
There is alot of incorrect info being repeated on the internet, such as the reason op rods cracked is becuase of firing grenades. This is also a internet myth
I have all correct SA 1941, SA 1943, SA 1944 and SA 1945 Garands all with uncut op rods and I do shoot them all. Am I taking a chance on them breaking? Maybe but the chance is very small. If it does crack I will simply buy another, they are not hard to find or that much premium over a standard op rod.
Just my opinion

I guess at this point we can agree to disagree. BTW sounds like you have a very nice collection. Congrats.

 

[dubsac]

tagged to learn

 

[jblomenberg16]

The going assumption on the un-cut op-rod is that it is worth more as-is, than if it is cracked. Many folks work really darn hard to find a "correct" gun and will usually pay a premium to get the exact right part to finish a build. While not as valuable as a documented original rifle, there are some collectors that do like a rifle with original parts for the receiver.

They did break during use in the field, hence the relief cut on many that were originally produced as un-cut, and the later design change to add a radius to relive the stress.

 

[Orlando8]

The going assumption on the un-cut op-rod is that it is worth more as-is, than if it is cracked. Many folks work really darn hard to find a "correct" gun and will usually pay a premium to get the exact right part to finish a build. While not as valuable as a documented original rifle, there are some collectors that do like a rifle with original parts for the receiver.

They did break during use in the field, hence the relief cut on many that were originally produced as un-cut, and the later design change to add a radius to relive the stress.

Yes of course, I agree

 

[Tula47]

Will be heading out to the shop after dinner to pickup that old thing. I'll post pictures later tonight

 

[Tula47]

Got all the dirt and grime removed.











Its still has some rust but I think the media in our sandblaster would be wayyy too abrasive.

 

[Orlando8]

I didnt realize the receiver andrear sight was that rusted/pitted. Thats a shame.
A old trick is to soak everything in old use motor oil for a few days then lightly rub with a scothbrite pad. This will remove the real light rust. If you plan on shooting this rifle the bolt will need to be dissasembled an cleaned, make sure the pin is not binding on rust et.
There really isnt any collector value since it has excess damage to the reciever. I would bet the barrel is toast. I wouldnt put any money into it until you have it inspected by somone who knows Garands to see if its safe to rebarrel
Good luck with your project

 

[maxipum]

Looks as though it may have been in a fire. If so be very carefull.

 

[So IN Dude]

Was that thing in a fire? Seems odd the handguard metal is still there.

 

[Orlando8]

You guys may be onto something,I bet you are right. May be best to turn it into a wallhanger

 

[wagyu52]

That's too bad, I wouldn't trust it that looks like it's been hot to me too. There's still plenty of good Garands around reasonably priced, I wouldn't put any money into refurbishing that, even as a wall hanger.

 

[Tula47]

I think I just found it a new home at the Indiana Military Museum. I'm going to clean it up and throw it in a stock for display purposes

 

[jblomenberg16]

Was that thing in a fire? Seems odd the handguard metal is still there.

Exactly what I was wondering after seeing the hand guard metal still in place like that. That would also explain the amount of surface rust. While a rifle will rust if left exposed to the elements, generally if it is stored inside it won't get that much rust on the parts that were parkerized like that. My grandpa brought a K98 back from WWII and it sat in his basement for 60 years, and there is only really light surface rust on it.

 

[Tula47]

I just met with the head of the museum and found a stock for it. He gave the green light to clean it up and get it to him to be parkerized and it will be on display in the museum in just a couple of weeks.

 

[Maximinus Thrax]

I just met with the head of the museum and found a stock for it. He gave the green light to clean it up and get it to him to be parkerized and it will be on display in the museum in just a couple of weeks.

I'm glad to see some good come out of it. A museum is a great place for it to rest.

 

[Tula47]

I'm glad to see some good come out of it. A museum is a great place for it to rest.

It'll function well as a display piece and I didn't have much in it so its a win win for everyone

 

[TJ Kackowski]

It'll function well as a display piece and I didn't have much in it so its a win win for everyone

Will the museum or you be doing something to make this rifle permanently non-functional? No telling what somebody down the road might try to do if this rifle appears to be functional.