Thanks for the great recommendations everyone!
After a morning's worth of internet "research", I'm going to try the N82 tuckable compact (thanks IndyTom).
The wife is starting to complain about my accumulation of holsters. She sees them for sale at the gun shows (those boxes for $5-10) and calculates the loss in her head....I bought a N82 Tuckable for my Shield and I hated it from the start. Maybe it's my body type, but it just doesn't work for me. So it sits in a drawer practically brand new.
I would recommend looking at the hard sided professional model if it's available for your pistol. I had the standard with the stretchy material and it collapses after you draw the gun. It made one-handed reholstering impossible and practicing the draw stroke was a real pain.