Could you post a picture of your round? That might help us. Those Berry's aren't cannelured are they? I believe that a taper crimp should be used if they do not have a crimp groove.
I've not used Unique but I do have good results with W231 and Titegroup in my .357. I can give you a load and even send a couple sample rounds your way if you like.
I haven't made up any more, so no pics I'm afraid. It's definitely time for a new powder. I might just splurge and grab a keg of each, Titegroup and 231. I'm sure I'll be able to put it to good use.
If this will help anyone, I finally got a good group out of the 125 gr Berry's bullets, but not in .38. I loaded some in the .357 magnum over 12.5 gr AA#9. I sparked it with Winchester Magnum primers. The book said 1390 fps, I didn't chrono them. It has a real snappy recoil and is plenty loud and a little smoky, but 20 shots went into just over 2 inches at 50 feet. That is 1/2 the size of the best group I ever got in the .38. Those little bugers need full throttle to fly right. I'll probably not be buying more.
I'm thinking the same thing. Some of my loads felt like they weren't getting complete ignition. The Unique might work better with a magnum primer, maybe I'll experiment with that.