I would put my money on the woman that has the appropriate Mind-Set regardless of training. I have seen highly trained martial artists fail miserably when faced with similar situations. On the other hand I have seen and read tons of reports of untrained people surviving assault, rape, murder, etc. with little or absolutely no previous training. The difference was their mental preparation, their tenacity, and their willingness to sometimes do the unthinkable to survive a bad situation.
Steve
Totally agree with this.
Being trained in a style is one thing. Being able to use it in a situation is another.
Every plan a person can formulate goes right out the window when you get blindsided or smashed in the mouth.
How you respond to that is what matters. Do you have the mindset to bite off an ear or a nose...??? It might come to that.
Until you actually get into a serious fight in the real world people have no idea of the ferocity they will encounter. Drug induced rage has no form. No style.
A female that is attacked from the blind with intent of harm or rape has but mere seconds to respond if even that. The same goes for a male being attacked in the same manner (with intent of harm) from a blind side.