Surplus Stores in Indiana

[Ogre]

Army-Navy Indianapolis Store

http://www.indyarmynavy.com
6032 East 21st Street, Indianapolis - (317) 356-0858

Joe's Army Navy Store

7023 Madison Avenue, Indianapolis (317) 781-1976

I didn't know Joes was still open...

 

[NathanJefferson]

Brooke's Army-Navy Surplus Str 5402 North College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220-3126(317) 255-8368‎

Thanks a ton! I know exactly where that is, but I never knew a surplus store was there! I've been to the restaurant/bar across the road many times.

 

[Tactical Dave]

I have a lot of good luck with the one on 21st street (listed in the original post).

Kinda a rough area though so stay alert.

Edit: I am hearing his prices have gone up quite a bit as of late.

I didn't know Joes was still open...

If it is right there near Soutport rd I am 99.9% sure it closed or moved years ago.

 

[Ogre]

I have a lot of good luck with the one on 21st street (listed in the original post).

Kinda a rough area though so stay alert.




If it is right there near Soutport rd I am 99.9% sure it closed or moved years ago.

yeah, I had been in there 15 yrs ago or so, and I was pretty sure it closed up, I just replied wondering if it had reopened but wasn't as visible from Madison or something

 

[Lex Concord]

Brian's Military Surplus
5925 E 00 Ns
Greentown, IN 46936-8773
(765) 628-3196

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store
2603 E State Road 44
Shelbyville, IN 46176
(317) 392-2266

Sgt. Smith's is a great place...owned by the same guy that owns Brooke's (his daughter's name) in Broad Ripple...retired USMC Sgt.

First time I was in there, they had surplus body armor (not flak, but actual armor) in ACU pattern (even up to XXL. Had I the cash at the time, it would be in my closet now...

 

[Lex Concord]

yeah, I had been in there 15 yrs ago or so, and I was pretty sure it closed up, I just replied wondering if it had reopened but wasn't as visible from Madison or something

I know he closed up the brick 'n' mortar side years ago and tried to go web only...looks like the web site is now defunct.

While I was looking, I found the following at this site:

EDIT: Well, that table didn't paste nicely....best to click the link above

​

Army-Navy Brooke's Surplus Store Inc
5402 North College Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220 317-255-8368 Army & Navy Camping Surplus Outlet
2989 West 71st Street, Indianapolis, IN 46268 317-293-3213 Army-Navy SGT Smith's Surplus Store Inc
2603 East State Road 44, Shelbyville, IN 46176 317-392-2266 Army Surplus Mid Lakes
101 S Washington Street, Pierceton, IN 46562 574-594-9464 Army Surplus Store
120 5th Street, North Vernon, IN 47265 812-346-2769 Army Navy Surplus
2989 West 71st Street, Indianapolis, IN 46268 317-293-3213 Army Surplus Store
712 S Main Street, North Webster, IN 46555 574-834-7212 Army Surplus
3714 16th Street, Bedford, IN 47421 812-275-2801 Army Surplus of Muncie
Sewing and Repair - Custom Holsters and Slings
1810 East Jackson Street, Muncie, IN 47305 765-281-8804
877-267-6601 Brian's Surplus
5925 East 00 Ns, Greentown, IN 46936 765-628-3196 Brooke's Army-Navy Surplus Store, Inc.
5402 N. College Ave., Indianapolis, IN 46220 317-255-8368 Enterprise Army Navy Surplus
120 E Us Highway 20, Angola, IN 46703 260-665-2283 GI Joe's Army Surplus
1638 North Wells Street, Fort Wayne, IN 46808 260-426-7859 Lee Army Surplus
2800 Clifty Drive, Madison, IN 47250
812-273-5081 McCullough Military Surplus
40 East National Avenue, Brazil, IN 47834 812-448-8882 Real Army Surplus
1126 North 1st Avenue, Evansville, IN 47710 812-424-4075 Sgt. Smith's Army-Navy Store, Inc.
2603 E. State Road 44, Shelbyville, IN 46176 317-392-CAMO The Supply Depot
3714 West 16th Street, Bedford IN 47421 812-275-2801 Townhouse Army Surplus
1037 West Commerce Street, Brownstown, IN 47220 812-358-3154
877-238-8151 Traildust Army Navy Surplus
4700 West State Road 45, Bloomington, IN 47403

 

[mrmarky]

I've been to McCullough's in Brazil and they are nice people alright but that store is the most messy place (retail) I've ever been in. they've prolly got it there ,,but good luck finding it!

 

[Indy317]

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store
2603 E State Road 44
Shelbyville, IN 46176
(317) 392-2266

Sgt. Smith's is a great place...owned by the same guy that owns Brooke's (his daughter's name) in Broad Ripple...retired USMC Sgt.

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store is no longer in Shelbyville. They moved the store to Rushville. They are located in the downtown area:103 N. Main St.; Rushville, IN 46173. http://www.sgtsmiths.com/Contact_Us.html

Last time I went in there, the guy working said they were trying to sell the Broad Ripple Store (Brooke's Army Navy). The store has a lot of room and they have a lot of equipment and stuff for sale.

 

[AK-NOW]

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store (317) 392-2266
2603 E State Road 44
Shelbyville, IN 46176

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store is no longer in Shelbyville. They moved the store to Rushville. They are located in the downtown area:103 N. Main St.; Rushville, IN 46173. http://www.sgtsmiths.com/Contact_Us.html

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store in Shelbyville closed over a year ago if not longer.

 

[SavageEagle]

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store is no longer in Shelbyville. They moved the store to Rushville. They are located in the downtown area:103 N. Main St.; Rushville, IN 46173. http://www.sgtsmiths.com/Contact_Us.html

Last time I went in there, the guy working said they were trying to sell the Broad Ripple Store (Brooke's Army Navy). The store has a lot of room and they have a lot of equipment and stuff for sale.

Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store (317) 392-2266
2603 E State Road 44
Shelbyville, IN 46176





Sgt. Smith's Army Navy Store in Shelbyville closed over a year ago if not longer.

Thanks for the update. Changed.

 

[mastery]

Every weekend when it's warm, I wonder where to ride the Harley to. Guess I've got some riding destinations now!

 

[SavageEagle]

Just wondering if this could be a sticky?

 

[Eddie]

Name: McCullough Military Surplus
Street: 40 East National Avenue
Brazil, in 47834-2603
Phone: (812) 448-8882

Good guy to deal with!

Yes. +1 to McCullough's. He is easy to deal with and doesn't mind if you spend an hour or so rummaging around.

 

[keith2210]

ill second making this a sticky. ive already made another thread before i saw this one. (which is exactly what i was looking for)

 

[shooter521]

Stickied per request.

 

[Tactical Dave]

Any Surplus stores in the central Indy area that has fair prices on MRE cases? Say $50-60????

 

[DocBoCook]

Any Surplus stores in the central Indy area that has fair prices on MRE cases? Say $50-60????

Not a chance.

And by the way, Brooke's is going out of business, according to signs on his windows

 

[SavageEagle]

Not a chance.

And by the way, Brooke's is going out of business, according to signs on his windows

Let me know when they do and I'll take it off the list.

 

[Tactical Dave]

Not a chance.

And by the way, Brooke's is going out of business, according to signs on his windows

Figured..... ebay has them for that but then charge $20 to ship it.

 

[E5RANGER375]

mre's have gone into rediculous price region. its stupid.

but so is buying from a surplus store. hardly ever will you find a deal in a surplus store that you cant get cheaper on ebay, even with shipping