Title IX vs Trans rights; who wins?

[BigRed]

Trans man and Satanic minister gives birth after one-night stand with fellow gay dating app user: 'Giving birth felt like one of the most masculine things I have done' | Blaze Media

A transgender man became pregnant after a one-night stand on a gay dating app — and he says that the experience "felt like one of the most masculine things" he's ever done. What are the details? According to the Daily Mail, 28-year-old Ash Patrick Schade — a self-described minister of Satan...

www.theblaze.com

"28-year-old Ash Patrick Schade — a self-described minister of Satan, mental health worker, and Ph.D. student"




I cannot help but wonder what kind of mental health work this gal does.

 

[rhamersley]

Trans man and Satanic minister gives birth after one-night stand with fellow gay dating app user: 'Giving birth felt like one of the most masculine things I have done' | Blaze Media

A transgender man became pregnant after a one-night stand on a gay dating app — and he says that the experience "felt like one of the most masculine things" he's ever done. What are the details? According to the Daily Mail, 28-year-old Ash Patrick Schade — a self-described minister of Satan...

www.theblaze.com

"28-year-old Ash Patrick Schade — a self-described minister of Satan, mental health worker, and Ph.D. student"




I cannot help but wonder what kind of mental health work this gal does.

UH...............I got nuthin...

 

[Chewie]

This reminds me of two quotes:
"If at first you don't succeed, redefine success."
"Torture the data long enough and it will confess to anything."

I may have occasion to use those quotes. Never heard them before.

 

[Twangbanger]

The new hotness is denying Title IX funds to schools who won't allow transes to compete on the team of their choice.

That is how they will get feminists in line. No transgender participation...no Title IX funds. If transes can't play "field tennis"...NObody can.

Done deal. Capitulation forthcoming. Next issue?

 

[Ingomike]

The new hotness is denying Title IX funds to schools who won't allow transes to compete on the team of their choice.

That is how they will get feminists in line. No transgender participation...no Title IX funds. If transes can't play "field tennis"...NObody can.

Done deal. Capitulation forthcoming. Next issue?

Is there not a SCOTUS case forthcoming?

 

[printcraft]

Because you cant have it both ways.

I mean, technically...

 

[rhamersley]

I may have occasion to use those quotes. Never heard them before.

I like "if at first you don't succeed, find a weaker opponent"...

 

[Mikey1911]

View attachment 79217

Same thing, different decade.

MH

I remember seeing this when it came out--in the good (?) old days where USA female Olympic athletes were having to compete (most commonly in swimming) with what looked like "altered males" from the CCCP and particularly from the DDR.

 

[Leadeye]

Law firms will be the only winners here. The law suits will be with you, always.

I think Twangbanger probably has the end game figured out,

Always follow the money

 

[Chewie]

I like "if at first you don't succeed, find a weaker opponent"...

That will do as well (but I've heard that one before).

 

[DoggyDaddy]

I like "if at first you don't succeed, find a weaker opponent"...

I like the Three Stooges version.

"If at first you don't succeed, keep on suckin' till you do suck seed!" It worked for Kamala too.

 

[Blackhawk2001]

Peterson is kinda right about order vs chaos. We may not have civil order exactly right in the West. Not everything can be fair. Since post modernism kinda removes the traditional order and replaces it with "everything is a social construct" or as you call it, "anything goes", it's essentially chaos. It turns the rules of society upside down and we're finding that only works for a small minority of people. The rules of society that makes order out of chaos kinda formed to solve these kinds of problems, and has determined that you can't make it fair for everyone.

The best we can get is to make it fairest for the most people. So we just have to say, I'm sorry that you have this disorder. But biological males aren't physical equals to biological females. You can't compete directly with them or it's unfair to them. You can't expect the vast majority of people to defer to your special conditions. And there's another issue that goes along with that. There are some females transitioning to males that still compete with other females. But because they're transitioning, they get to take testosterone, which is a performance enhancing drug that is banned for everyone else.

So the rules to prevent chaos: 1) Biological males transitioning to females can't compete against females. Ever. Even after transitioning, they still have many of the physical advantages of males that make their participation unfair to biological women. Under no circumstances can anyone compete while taking testosterone or other performance enhancing drugs. No exceptions. That's not transphobic. It's not fair to everyone. But it's the fairest we can get.

Maybe we need tranny leagues.

Jamil may have been being sarcastic, but I think he's stated the only "fair" solution to the problem. Let transitioning/transitioned males & females compete against each other and no one else.

 

[Shadow01]

Every female athlete pushed out of athletics by this nonsense is a possible new conservative. Ruining female sports will make more conservative women than an other effort ever will.

 

[Twangbanger]

Every female athlete pushed out of athletics by this nonsense is a possible new conservative. Ruining female sports will make more conservative women than an other effort ever will.

See, that's what sucks about this. The affected minority is small, and the Left realizes it. Only a small portion of girls play individual sports where a stronger individual can beat you. And of that small portion, an even smaller portion ever had a chance of winning, anyway. The only girls who are really being deprived are the ones playing individual sports, _and_ who were good enough to potentially win...until the "childhood traumatized doods" came along. All the rest of girl athletes are either playing team sports where individual strength isn't as decisive, or are also-rans in individual sports who were never going to win anyway.

And of the portion of individual athletes potentially deprived of titles, you have to figure that some portion of them are leftists, themselves.

So the aggrieved minority is small, and therefore, no critical mass of deprived individuals builds up to where a sea-change can occur. The Woke Wolf picks off the weakest baby from the herd...and the herd keeps on running.

 

[Ingomike]

See, that's what sucks about this. The affected minority is small, and the Left realizes it. Only a small portion of girls play individual sports where a stronger individual can beat you. And of that small portion, an even smaller portion ever had a chance of winning, anyway. The only girls who are really being deprived are the ones playing individual sports, _and_ who were good enough to potentially win...until the "childhood traumatized doods" came along. All the rest of girl athletes are either playing team sports where individual strength isn't as decisive, or are also-rans in individual sports who were never going to win anyway.

And of the portion of individual athletes potentially deprived of titles, you have to figure that some portion of them are leftists, themselves.

So the aggrieved minority is small, and therefore, no critical mass of deprived individuals builds up to where a sea-change can occur. The Woke Wolf picks off the weakest baby from the herd...and the herd keeps on running.

This is just wrong! Millions of young girls depend scholarships for college that can easily be lost to biological males…

 

[Twangbanger]

This is just wrong! Millions of young girls depend scholarships for college that can easily be lost to biological males…

No argument here. But then again, you're talking about a group of people who just think college should be free, anyway, so they're unconstrained by any kind of reality-based reasoning.

 

[bwframe]

 

[Shadow01]

If trans can demand to participate in women's sports, why not have women demand to participate in nontran’s sports?

 

[Ingomike]

Que the corporate oligarchs to threaten the state if they do not do their bidding…

 

[DoggyDaddy]

If trans can demand to participate in women's sports, why not have women demand to participate in nontran’s sports?

What are nontran's sports? And FTR, I agree completely with this bill.