I certainly understand your point. There is more to the story, but I won't be posting it in a public forum. I can see now that it looks bad the way I've framed it.
Maybe you'd still disagree knowing the whole story. All I can say is that I stand by my decision. Hard to say what would have happened if I had just arrested her. The outcome would likely be much the same, except her picture would be on the inmate search page of the jail. Charges may still be coming. This was likely the best outcome for her. She was going to lose her job either way.
Thank you for your private message. It explained a lot. I think the confusion was in describing it as a traffic stop. I immediately thought, "pulled over, license and registration please".
To anyone else, not that it matters, but I understand his actions and see why he went that route.
And how did her boss know anything besides her side of the story? More importantly, how do you know about how her boss feels?
It seems to me that she was guilty of refusal to identify which is a misdemeanor. Fine, take her to jail. You said that you found another way to deal with the issue - did you call her boss and tell him that she was being naughty?
I'm really hoping that I'm wrong. If I am, I'll be happy to remove my posts and apologize, but it seems like you abused your position of authority.
That's like 30 mph more than everyone else goes on that stretch.
CPD Commander demoted & relieved of powers. Is this a sign of positive change or is he a sacrificial lamb to the Chicago machine?
Chicago Tribune: CPD commander relieved of powers, demoted following Indiana traffic stop investigation.